Why Do People Die Sooner in Nursing Homes and Assisted Living Facilities
Know your options before signing on the dotted line.
***Research and Article (not introduction) performed and written by Chris Orestis***
James F Fries, MD, pioneered the concept of the compression of morbidity in 1980 with his journal article in The New England Journal of Medicine entitled, “Aging, Natural Death, and the Compression of Morbidity”. This content speaks on why people die sooner in nursing homes and assisted living facilities. Since then there has been further research, reviews, and articles released expounding on the negative implications associated with admittance into institutionalized long term care settings. The original article is an excellent read and I would recommend it to anyone!
Life Expectancy has been on an upward trajectory for over 100 years. According to the most recent report released by the AARP, the age group 65 and above will increase 89% over the next twenty years, and the 85 and older population will grow 74% during the same period.
This rise in life expectancy, and the impact on quality of life was explored by James F. Fries in his 1982 study for the National Academy of Sciences entitled “The Compression of Morbidity”. In the paper, Fries contends that the aging population will live longer and in much better condition for a longer period of time due to improved lifestyles, nutrition, exercise, abstinence, and education. The flip side of this dynamic is that once people experience a disease or injury that requires long term care, the result is most often a dramatic decrease of life expectancy. For example, an age appropriately healthy 78 year old that lives an independent and active lifestyle might have a life expectancy of 15 years or greater. If that same individual suffered physical trauma or a disorder that required a move into a long term care facility, their life expectancy could be reduced 50%-75%.
The Assisted Living and Skilled Nursing Home (Senior Living) industry currently houses approximately 2,000,000 people across 60,000 facilities in the United States. This represents one of the biggest components of our country’s health care system and as an industry, theses facilities experience the impact of “Life Expectancy Compression” on a daily basis. Average “length of stay” is a carefully tracked industry benchmark for determining turnover and occupancy metrics. In the annual State of the Senior Housing Industry report released by the American Senior Housing Association (ASHA) the Senior Living industry reported average length of stay in 2008: Assisted Living (21 months), Independent Living (38 months), CCRC (77 months) and Alzheimer’s Care (17 months).
According to the National Center for Assisted Living (NCAL), of those currently residing in an assisted living community 34% will move to a skilled nursing facility due to deteriorating health and 30% will die. The mortality rate of individuals moving into a skilled nursing facility is death within the first 12 months by as much as 50%-60%. The mortality rate is even higher in the first 6 months.
In addition to length of stay experience, there are a number of studies that have been conducted measuring life expectancy across significant population cohorts in various forms of long term care settings:
In the study Mortality-related factors and 1-year survival in nursing home residents it was concluded from a population of over 100,000 residents during a three year period: “Major factors associated with 1-year mortality were identified in both the newly admitted and long-stay cohorts. MDS data can identify major factors associated with 1-year mortality in newly admitted and long-stay nursing home residents.” The first year of residence in a nursing home is the highest risk of death for the resident.
The research paper Death Rates Following Nursing Home & Care Facility Placement concludes: “There is evidence that people with dementia admitted to nursing homes and care facilities die comparatively quickly. It is known that mortality rates are high, initially, when people move from their own homes. Mortality rates are especially high in nursing homes.” The mortality rate for an individual moving into an Alzheimer’s care unit within the first year is greater than 50%.
In recent years the insurance industry has begun taking a closer look at the unique factors of underwriting seniors. As more insurance products are sold to higher risk populations, it has become critical to better understand factors impacting morbidity and mortality. Senior Vice President and Chief Medical Officer of RGA Reinsurance Company, J. Carl Holowaty, MD, DBIM, stated in a 2009 paper published in the Journal of the Academy of Life Underwriting that loss of ADL’s (activities of daily living: bathing, dressing, toileting, transferring, and continence) increases the risk of death. He also cites “will to live” in the elderly “must be taken very seriously” and that there is a relationship between mortality and degree of social engagement and changes in social patterns over time. Moving into an institutional care facility is possibly the single most disruptive event to patterns of social engagement that a person could experience (ranking maybe even higher than the death of a spouse).
What has been observed by daily experience throughout the entire long term care industry, and supported by numerous studies, is that individuals living in institutional care (regardless of age) will have significantly shorter life expectancies than their contemporaries living independently. Mortality is not only driven by their condition, but also by the impact of the significant change in environment. There are intangible factors such as “will to live” and tangible factors such as exposure to communicable diseases in the group environment that all come together to “compress” their life expectancy. Until very recently, actuarial tables and life expectancy calculations have ignored this well known and well documented fact. But now, the reality of this dynamic is becoming more important as the population of people reaching the compression point is increasing. Accurate underwriting in today’s “Silver Tsunami” driven world must take into account that people may be living longer and healthier lives, but when they cross the morbidity threshold, their life expectancies drop dramatically.
1) Length of Stay Data, Group 1 (Skilled Nursing Provider)
Medicaid admissions= 149 residents @ 379 days
Private Pay admissions= 77 residents @ 335 days
2) Length of Stay Data, Group 2 (Assisted Living Provider)
44 deceased residents with a combined average length of stay of 2.9 years
– 75% female
– 25% male
**The content written in this article was not the work of Michelle Eliason, sole credit given to Chris Orestis a leader in the long term care industry with 15+ years of professional experience. Thank you for this valuable review and compilation of the effect of institutionalization residency. **
- American Seniors Housing Association, The State of Senior Housing, 2008
Death Rates Following Nursing Homes & Care Facility Placement: http://alzheimers.about.com/od/caregivers/a/surv_nurs_homes.htm
- Mortality-related factors and 1-year survival in nursing home residents: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/12558718
- Mortality, Disability, and Nursing Home Use for Persons with and without Hip Fracture: A Population-Based Study: http://pt.wkhealth.com/pt/re/jags/abstract.00004495-20021000000005.htm;jsessionid=KQNQ9hz1WyBL5gzxJTCyh2y2PWYj6FQs2mKGrcYjjpVndtf9g7jP!331639832!181195628!8091!-1
- 2008 MetLife Market Survey of Nursing Homes and Assisted Living Costs: http://www.metlife.com/assets/cao/mmi/publications/studies/mmi-studies-2008-nhal-costs.pdf
- Demographic Profile of 65+ Population : http://www.metlife.com/assets/cao/mmi/publications/studies/mmi-studies-65-profile-20041010.pdf
- Demographic Profile of American Baby Boomers: http://www.metlife.com/assets/cao/mmi/publications/studies/mmi-studies-boomer-profile-2007.pdf
- Nursing Homes Fact Sheet , AARP Public Policy Institute: http://www.aarp.org/research/longtermcare/nursinghomes/aresearch-import-669-FS10R.html
- The Silver Tsunami: http://www.lifecarefunding.com/whitepapers/LifeCareFundingGroupWhitePaper8-08SilverTsunami.pdf
- Brown Atlas of Dying: http://www.chcr.brown.edu/dying/BROWNATLAS.HTM
- CDC, National Center for Health Statistics: http://www.cdc.gov/nchs/default.htm
- The Compression of Morbidity: http://www.milbank.org/quarterly/830427fries.pdf